| Name | Score | Price | City |
|---|---|---|---|
| Burattino Brick Oven Pizza | 8.8 | $40.67 | Toronto |
| Maker Pizza | 8.9 | $38.42 | Toronto |
| Blondies Pizza | 9 | $26.84 | Toronto |
| Superpoint Pizza | 8.8 | $36.16 | Toronto |
| Pizzeria Libretto | 8.5 | $22.60 | Toronto |
| The Fourth Man in the Fire | 8.6 | $38.14 | Toronto |
| Fresca Pizza and Pasta | 6.5 | $15.00 | Toronto |
| Pizza Gigi | 8.7 | $21.95 | Toronto |
| One Night Only Pizza | 8.7 | $32.77 | Toronto |
| Descendant Detroit Style | 8.3 | $38.42 | Toronto |
| Pizzeria Oro Di Napoli | 8.6 | $22.60 | Etobicoke |
| FBI Pizza | 7.2 | $21.53 | Etobicoke |